Prompt 3 of 7
Name an ice cream flavor
92 accepted answers across 6 rarity tiers.
100 ptsOne in a Krillion1 answer
The rarest possible answer — almost no player finds it.
- Cherry Garcia— Named for the Grateful Dead's Jerry Garcia. The first ice cream named after a living person. Ben & Jerry's consulted him. He approved. The Dead ran on ice cream and music.
85 ptsDeep Cut40 answers
Genuinely obscure. Most players never think of it.
- Black sesame
- Blue moon
- Cardamom
- Chai
- Chocolate malt
- Chunky Monkey
- Cinnamon
- Cookie butter
- Dulce de leche
- Durian
- Earl Grey
- Eggnog
- Grape
- Grape-Nut
- Guava
- Half Baked
- Honey lavender
- Horchata
- Lavender
- Lychee
- Melon
- Mud pie
- Pandan
- Passion fruit
- Phish Food
- Pina colada
- Red bean
- Red velvet
- Rose
- Saffron
- Superman
- Sweet corn
- Sweet cream
- Taro
- Teaberry
- Thai tea
- Tiger tail
- Tiramisu
- Ube
- Watermelon
60 ptsRare34 answers
Uncommon — only a minority of players land here.
- Almond
- Banana
- Birthday cake
- Black currant
- Black raspberry
- Black walnut
- Blackberry
- Blueberry
- Butterscotch
- Cheesecake
- Cherry
- Chocolate brownie
- Coconut
- Hazelnut
- Honey
- Honeycomb
- Key lime
- Lemon
- Mango
- Maple walnut
- Orange creamsicle
- Peach
- Peanut butter
- Pralines and cream
- Pumpkin
- Rainbow sherbet
- Raspberry
- Rum raisin
- S'mores
- Salted caramel
- Spumoni
- Stracciatella
- Toffee
- Tutti frutti
30 ptsSchooler13 answers
A solid, middling pick shared with plenty of other players.
- Bubblegum
- Butter pecan
- Caramel
- Chocolate chip
- Coffee
- Cookie dough
- Cookies and cream
- Cotton candy
- Mint chocolate chip
- Moose tracks
- Neapolitan
- Pistachio
- Rocky road
15 ptsToo Clever1 answer
An overthought pick that scores below the middle of the board.
- Matcha— The flavor that signals you have Opinions About Ice Cream. Earthy, complex, bitter. And very much a personality trait.
10 ptsPlankton3 answers
The most common answer on the board.
- Chocolate
- Strawberry
- Vanilla