Prompt 3 of 7
Name a type of pie
69 accepted answers across 6 rarity tiers.
100 ptsOne in a Krillion1 answer
The rarest possible answer — almost no player finds it.
- Stargazy pie— A Cornish pie with whole fish heads poking through the crust to gaze at the stars. Truly nobody blurts this out.
85 ptsDeep Cut25 answers
Genuinely obscure. Most players never think of it.
- Apricot pie
- Bakewell tart
- Black bottom pie
- Boysenberry pie
- Buttermilk pie
- Butterscotch pie
- Concord grape pie
- Cranberry pie
- Derby pie
- Elderberry pie
- Frito pie
- Grasshopper pie
- Huckleberry pie
- Lemon icebox pie
- Maple syrup pie
- Marionberry pie
- Moon pie
- Pork pie
- S'mores pie
- Scotch pie
- Sugar cream pie
- Tamale pie
- Tarte Tatin
- Treacle tart
- Walnut pie
60 ptsRare23 answers
Uncommon — only a minority of players land here.
- Banoffee pie
- Boston cream pie
- Buko pie
- Chess pie
- Coconut cream pie
- Cottage pie
- Custard pie
- Dutch apple pie
- Fish pie
- French silk pie
- Gooseberry pie
- Hand pie
- Ice cream pie
- Mince pie
- Mixed berry pie
- Mud pie
- Oreo pie
- Peanut butter pie
- Raspberry pie
- Rhubarb pie
- Steak and kidney pie
- Sweet potato pie
- Tomato pie
30 ptsSchooler15 answers
A solid, middling pick shared with plenty of other players.
- Banana cream pie
- Blackberry pie
- Blueberry pie
- Chicken pot pie
- Chocolate cream pie
- Cream pie
- Key lime pie
- Lemon meringue pie
- Meat pie
- Peach pie
- Pecan pie
- Pizza pie
- Shepherd's pie
- Strawberry pie
- Strawberry rhubarb pie
15 ptsToo Clever2 answers
An overthought pick that scores below the middle of the board.
- Shoofly pie— The Pennsylvania Dutch molasses pick that food nerds deploy to sound folksy.
- Whoopie pie— A cake sandwich wearing a pie's name tag — but Boston cream got in, so fairness prevails.
10 ptsPlankton3 answers
The most common answer on the board.
- Apple pie
- Cherry pie
- Pumpkin pie