Prompt 1 of 7
Name a Caribbean island
59 accepted answers across 6 rarity tiers.
100 ptsOne in a Krillion1 answer
The rarest possible answer — almost no player finds it.
- Petite Martinique— A speck off Grenada, barely a square mile, historically a boatbuilding and smuggling haven. Trench floor of the Caribbean.
85 ptsDeep Cut30 answers
Genuinely obscure. Most players never think of it.
- Abaco
- Ambergris Caye
- Andros
- Anegada
- Barbuda
- Bequia
- Bimini
- Bonaire
- Carriacou
- Cayo Coco
- Culebra
- Eleuthera
- Exuma
- Hispaniola— The whole island shared by Haiti and the Dominican Republic. The one people forget has a name.
- Isla de la Juventud
- Isla Mujeres
- Margarita Island
- Marie-Galante
- New Providence
- Providencia
- Roatan
- Saba
- Saint Barthelemy
- Saint Croix
- Saint John
- San Andres
- Sint Eustatius
- Tortola
- Vieques— A Puerto Rican island with a bay that glows blue with bioluminescence.
- Virgin Gorda
60 ptsRare15 answers
Uncommon — only a minority of players land here.
- Anguilla
- Cayman Islands
- Cozumel
- Curacao
- Grand Bahama
- Guadeloupe
- Martinique
- Montserrat— Half of it is an exclusion zone under an active volcano.
- Nevis
- Saint Kitts
- Saint Martin
- Saint Thomas
- Saint Vincent
- Tobago
- Turks and Caicos
30 ptsSchooler7 answers
A solid, middling pick shared with plenty of other players.
- Antigua
- Aruba
- Dominican Republic
- Grenada
- Haiti
- Saint Lucia
- Trinidad
15 ptsToo Clever1 answer
An overthought pick that scores below the middle of the board.
- Dominica— Not the Dominican Republic. The 'well actually' pick, and yes we know they're different.
10 ptsPlankton5 answers
The most common answer on the board.
- Bahamas
- Barbados
- Cuba
- Jamaica
- Puerto Rico